December 23, 2022
What’s the Best Protein Source for Dogs: Meat, Meat Meals or By-Products?
With so many different dog food recipes made with different types of protein to choose from, we know it can be hard to make the right decision. You might be asking questions like what the best protein sources for dogs are, or how to read an ingredient panel to know what’s actually in your dog’s food. You might also be wondering what the difference between chicken meal and chicken by-product meal is, or deboned turkey vs. turkey meal, or what it means when just “meat meal” is listed.
Protein content and its sources are often marketed as the most important part of a pet food, and when there’s so many different kinds out there, it can make the decision feel overwhelming. To help you out next time you’re at the local pet food shop or researching online, let’s dig into the what’s and why’s of all things protein!
What is protein, and why do dogs need it?
Protein is one of three macronutrients (meaning nutrients the body requires in large amounts), along with fat and carbohydrates, which make up pet foods. Proteins are made of building blocks called amino acids, which are important for many key functions in the body, including healthy muscle development and recovery. Amino acids from protein are essential for healthy muscles – no other nutrient can do this task! Meat ingredients are one of the main sources of this important nutrient, and also play an important role in contributing to the flavor and texture of your dog’s meal.
In total, dogs require 22 amino acids. 12 of these amino acids are called non-essential, meaning the body can make them using other nutrients. The remaining 10 are called essential amino acids because dogs must receive them through their diet.
Best protein source for dogs
It's important to note that it’s not the protein source that matters most, rather, it’s about finding the right balance of amino acids. This is why there is no single best protein source for dogs, however whole eggs are what’s considered a 'perfect' protein because they contain all the essential amino acids dogs need.
It’s not the protein source that matters most, rather, it’s about finding the right balance of amino acids. This is why there is no single best protein source for dogs, however whole eggs are what’s considered a 'perfect' protein because they contain all the essential amino acids dogs need.
Ultimately, it is the amino acids found in the protein, that the body needs. In fact, whether an amino acid comes from an animal or plant source doesn’t matter to the body – it just knows it needs that amino acid. Choosing recipes made with complementary meat and plant-based protein ingredients (like sustainably produced peas), meaning they balance each other out to complete the amino acid profile, is often a great choice.
Every protein source, from fresh meat and whole eggs, to dried meat meals and legumes, contains different amounts of those essential amino acids, which means a diet that contains multiple protein sources is a great way to help ensure your pet is getting the amino acids they need.
Another option is to consider a varied diet and switching up proteins for your dog every so often. A varied diet to switch up proteins for your dog comes with benefits. Research even suggests that feeding a variety of protein and other foods, especially when started at a young age, can help the good gut bacteria easily recognize new food sources (Castellazzi et al, 2013). This may help discourage the development of food sensitivities later in life.
What are meat meals, meat by-product meals?
Named meat meals are a concentrated, dried protein ingredient from a single animal source. These would appear on an ingredient panel as “chicken meal” or “lamb meal” – note only a single, named, animal source. Meat meals which appear on a label without a specific named animal source (also known as "unnamed meat meals") can come from a number of different unknown sources and are best to be avoided.
Named meat meals are created by taking fresh meat, nutrient rich bones and cartilage, cooking it to remove the water and fat, and then grinding the dried meat into a concentrated, protein-rich powder.
Meat By-Product Meals
Meat by-products include all the other parts of the body other than muscle meat. This can include things like nutrient-rich organ meats, as well as undesirable ingredients like heads and feet.
Meat by-product meals are created using the same cooking process as meat meals and may be from a single animal source, but the actual animal parts in the meal can be a wide array of things. On an ingredient panel, this would be labelled as “chicken by-product meal” or “pork by-product meal.”
Are by-product meals bad for dogs?
There are no set inclusion levels for the types of by-products that can be used in by-product meals. This means it’s often made up of a wide array of ingredients that vary in nutritional quality, from liver to chicken feet. So, while some batches of a by-product meal may be well made and highly nutritious, it's impossible to know for sure.
When it comes down to choosing the right recipe for your dog, a good rule to live by is to look for simple, whole ingredients you recognize from your own grocery shopping. Foods like fresh meats, vegetables, and fruits with familiar ingredient names is an easy way to understand exactly what you’re feeding your dog.
How does fresh meat compare to meat meals?
Named meat meals can be very high-quality sources of protein, but fresh meat does offer a few key benefits. First, and most importantly, is that fresh meat does not go through the separate high heat cooking process that meat meals do; fresh meat is minimally processed, meaning its cooked only once, which helps to preserve nutrients and deliver the best nutritional value to your dog. Because it’s less processed, it’s also easy for pets to digest, making it a great option for dogs with sensitive stomachs, and adds a great taste to your pet’s meal.
Research published in the journal, Animals (Montegiove et al, 2022) has shown that kibble using only fresh meats is higher in amino acid content as compared to those using only meat meals or a combination of the two. The authors found that dry pet food using only fresh chicken meat was the highest in essential amino acids, branched-chain amino acids and taurine. It also had a higher amount of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids. In addition, its digestibility was the highest of all foods tested. These findings make the fresh-meat-based formulation a preferable choice as dry pet food.
Research published in the journal, Animals (Montegiove et al, 2022) has shown that kibble using only fresh meats is higher in amino acid content as compared to those using only meat meals or a combination of the two ... In addition, its digestibility was the highest of all foods tested. These findings make the fresh-meat-based formulation a preferable choice as dry pet food.
Second, meat meals contain bone, meaning they usually have a high level of minerals, namely phosphorous, calcium, and magnesium. Fresh meats do not contain bone, meaning the foods made with them are lower in mineral content. This controlled mineral content can help with health issues, such as kidney disease or urinary issues like struvite crystals, which can be related to high mineral content.
Though fresh meat has numerous benefits, it does often come with a higher cost as compared to concentrated meat meals. This is because fresh meats have not yet been processed and is still in its raw form. When fresh meat is processed into a meat meal, the moisture is removed to create a concentrated protein. This means that it can take 3-5 lbs of fresh meat to create 1 lb of meat meal. It also means that more fresh meat is required in fresh meat-only recipes to achieve the same level of protein as a meat meal-only dog food.
Additionally, pairing fresh meats with complimentary protein-rich plant ingredients and eggs is a beneficial way to achieve the desired level of protein, while making sure your dog is getting a variety of premium-quality protein sources. In this way, NOW FRESH has been able to incorporate fresh and simple ingredients, offering pets a delicious, complete, and balanced meal, that pet parents can feel good about feeding.
Simply put, fresh meat costs more. Fresh meat is high in moisture, so more meat is required to reach the ideal protein levels than a meat meal recipe. Blending complementary fresh meat with complementary egg and plant ingredients is a great way to complete the protein profile.
How much protein should a dog have?
As with most things in life, it’s important to consider both quality and quantity of protein. But, don’t fall into the trap of thinking more protein is automatically better! Dogs (and humans, for that matter), can only use so much protein for those important functions like muscle development. Anything more than the amount they need can turn into body fat or be passed out of the body in urine.
Dogs (and humans, for that matter), can only use so much protein for those important functions like muscle development. Anything more than the amount they need can turn into body fat or be passed out of the body in urine.
It’s important to remember that every dog is different, and the amount of protein they need will vary depending on their size, age, and activity level. According to the American Association of Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), which is the primary organization that provides recommendations for pet food in North America, adult dogs require a minimum of 18% protein in their food (on a dry matter basis). From our experience, most dogs do great on a diet ranging from 22-26%. Highly active dogs, working dogs, and puppies usually will need a higher protein percentage to keep them in tip-top shape and support their growth and development.
What’s NOW FRESH’s approach to protein?
NOW FRESH dog food recipes use complimentary meat and plant protein sources from fresh meats, like turkey salmon and duck, plus eggs and legumes, to provide all the essential amino acids that dogs need. We tailor our recipes to your dog’s life stage and breed size and use balanced protein levels for each to help your dog maintain a healthy weight.
Our choice to use high quality fresh meat sources helps keep our recipes minimally processed and easy for pets to digest – plus fresh meats add a taste and texture that dogs love. Since NOW FRESH doesn’t use meat meals, or meat by-products, our recipes have controlled mineral levels, which can also help to support urinary tract health.
NOW FRESH Dry Food Recipes for Dogs
NOW FRESH recipes use minimally processed fresh de-boned meats and fish, like turkey, salmon and duck, whole eggs, and sustainable plant proteins in balanced proportions that are tailored to your dog’s life stage and breed size.
Find a Recipe
At the end of the day
Not all protein sources are created equally, and more protein does not mean better nutrition. Protein serves specific functions in the body and can contribute to the palatability of a food; certain functions can only be completed by using amino acids from protein, but anything provided in excess is not beneficial and may contribute to health issues down the road. When choosing a food for your pup, ensure that it is compete and balanced for their individual size and life stage, and that the ingredients used are those which you feel best suit your pet’s needs and palate and your values.
NOW FRESH is uncompromising on the quality of our ingredients, choosing to use only premium-quality protein sources in their most simple, natural, and wholesome form, and then tailored to your dog’s stage of life and breed size. Should you have questions about the recipes, or finding a fit for your dog, reach out to our health and nutrition specialists at 866-864-6112 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Montegiove, N., Calzoni, E., Cesaretti, A., Pellegrino, RM., Emiliani, C., Pellegrino, A., & Leonardi, L.2022. The Hard Choice about Dry Pet Food: Comparison of Protein and Lipid Nutritional Qualities and Digestibility of Three Different Chicken-Based Formulations. Animals. Vol 12(12).
Castellazzi, AM., Valsecchi, C., Caimmi, S., Licari, A., Marseglia, A., Leoni, MC., Caimmi, D., Miraglia del Giudice, M., Leonardi, S., La Rosa, M., & Marseglia, GL. 2013. Probiotics and food allergy. Ital J Pediatr. Vol 39(47).